skip to content »

Laws regarding teen dating violence in canada

A couple of decades ago, there was a widespread perception that domestic abuse was strictly a private matter.That changed dramatically after a series of inquests into slain spouses -- not to mention considerable lobbying by concerned women's groups. Although developed as a life line for women unable to stand up to brutish spouses, critics say zero tolerance is tying the hands of police officers at the same time as it patronizes women and destroys their families.

"He hasn't had contact with his family for eight, 12 or 16 months," Mr. Brodsky says that unless a defendant or the complainant pays for a lawyer and privately commission a psychiatric report to show the presiding judge, "it is almost impossible to fight a no-contact order." Another Toronto lawyer, Tanya Kranjc, has managed to overturn five no-contact orders on behalf of complainants.The rigid measures of zero tolerance usually result in: Laying assault or threatening charges virtually any time a woman makes an abuse claim, whether or not she agrees to it. Imposing orders that force defendants out of the family home.Keeping prosecutions going even after spouses have resolved their differences.They say it blithely reduces the complexity of crime and punishment to a one-size-fits-all philosophy, indiscriminately entangling both serious and small-time offenders in its dragnet."This is the area of my practice where I see the greatest potential for injustice," says Robert Rotenberg, the lawyer who represented Mr. "Whatever happened to our notion of people as individuals?It makes no difference whether the complainant weeps and cajoles the Crown until she is blue in the face: The machinery is in motion. You have marriages ending after 18 years because someone reached out and grabbed an arm." Lawyer Dan Brodsky says the no-contact orders are often imposed without the complainant even being warned.

"Most people don't know that calling 911 is like pressing the nuclear button," Toronto defence lawyer Alan Gold remarks. The defendant is given 20 or 30 minutes to remove his belongings from the home, while a police officer stands guard.

The numbers of young people suffering from depression in the last 10 years has risen worryingly, an expert says.

BBC, UK, August 3, 2004 Government statistics suggest one in eight adolescents now has depression.

There is this underlying generalization that lumps every man in with the most extreme cases.

You can't run a justice system through stereotypes." Across the country, each province developed its own strict guidelines for police and crown attorneys to follow.

Because they think every family is going to kill each other?